After two years I’ve recently found myself single. It is the first time I have been single since graduating college. I knew I was going to date this guy from the moment I met him. I just knew it in my gut. No, I am not crazy and wasn’t doodling his last name in my diary fantasizing about our life together but I just knew he was a guy I could and would date. Ironically enough, I’m one of the most indecisive people you’ll meet but when it comes to guys I know immediately what I want. He was handsome, intelligent, graduated from a great university, driven, into food and wine and basically the antithesis of the frat boys I had been surrounded by the past four years. He was great on paper. In the sea of mutts, he was the pure bread I wanted and yearned to be. We went on a date the following Monday which only solidified the connection. We split a bottle of Chianti and closed the restaurant discussing our childhoods, our families, our likes and dislikes, food, our dreams and goals; it seemed we were destined to meet in some rom com style pairing. He seemed to be the male version of myself and it just worked.
After that first date things moved pretty quickly: we became exclusive, took a trip to San Francisco for a wine tasting, met each other’s coworkers and friends all in the span of a month. We were in that honeymoon phase where everything he did was adorable (including things that became beyond obnoxious), we couldn’t keep our hands off of each other and we wanted to spend every moment with each other. We were a movie montage without the pop soundtrack. I was head over heels for the guy who was great on paper. I was at a time in my life when everything was so uncertain: I had just graduated from college and wasn’t a stone’s throw from all of my friends, I hated my job and for the first time wasn’t sure what I was going to do with my life and felt generally out of control. He was the only thing that seemed certain and stable in my life. Even as the shine of the relationship wore off and I noticed more qualities that were great on paper but weren’t as great in my reality, I still liked having him around. I started to tell girlfriends that I knew we wouldn’t be together forever but he was good for now. Some were confused and unsure why I would be with someone who I know I didn’t have a future with. I didn’t know that at twenty-something I was only supposed to be dating potential life partners. As time wore on and our relationship became comfortable like a worn pair of converse, things about him that I once thought were great started to bother me more. His advice to me on my career and life in general started to seem more condescending and patriarchal than caring and loving. His thirty minute nighttime regimen which was much longer than mine seemed more high maintenance than well groomed. His need for $800 dollar Hugo Boss suits and professional shaves seemed more 1% than 99%. These annoyances built up inside me and at times I felt suffocated by our relationship. But we didn’t fight. We weren’t jealous. We had a good enough time when we were together. Sometimes even great. The sex was still great when we did have it. Nothing was wrong with the relationship, but nothing was right. We were indifferent which might be the worst. The passion was gone. And the guy that was good on paper was just that: good on paper but not in reality.
Maybe it was my ego, but I thought I was the only one feeling unsatisfied in our relationship. With a tentative move to New York on the horizon for me, I figured I’d ride it out, enjoy the stability and mediocrity and we could make a clean break when I left. It was definitely a copout but it was easier than breaking up with him because it didn’t feel right after almost two years. Well after my roommate and her boyfriend broke up after three years, our relationship issues could not be suppressed any longer. As I heard him say “we need to talk” my face turned pale. How could he “we need to talk” before I could do it to him?! I thought he was ecstatic with our mediocre relationship. As we began to talk, I realized he felt the same way I did. I was his “good on paper” girl and we both desperately needed new writing supplies.
So we ended things. It was awkward, uncomfortable and the most adult breakup I’ve had thus far. No ill words were said (though I thought some in the heat of the moment), pleasantries were exchanged and we wished each other the best. I was back to having no stability in my life: I was excited, scared, nervous and worried. But it was better than dating a piece of paper.


